Tag Archives: genealogy

Fair Use?

cheshire cat

Stanford University Libraries’ Fairly Used Blog published a post on  22 December 2014 entitled

How much of a photo do you need to alter to avoid copyright infringement? Hint: Cheshire Cat

It poses a interesting case.  You can read the summary of the  US  7th Circuit court affirmation of a lower court decision that the image at the left here was fair  use of the photograph on Justia.com. (1)

Fair Use is a complicated issue and every case is judged on it’s own merit.  Every time I think I have a good handle on the issue another question arises that doesn’t fit or another decision is made that seems counter to previous decisions.  The best we can do is to follow the rules as best we can and keep ourselves informed on current issues and decisions.

The following links offer some interesting discussions on the issue of Fair Use.

  • You Tube has a page dedicated to Fair Use, where they give examples of uses of copyright protected materials for criticism, news reporting and remix.
  • The Digital Media Law website has helpful Fair Use page with a discussion of use of email and private letters.
  • The Center for Media and Social Impact in conjunction with The Association of Research Libraries and
    The Program on information Justice and Intellectual Property has developed The Code of Best Practices in Fair Use for Academic and Research Libraries which seems pertinent to researchers and preservationist of all ilk, including genealogists.\
  • University of Texas has a Copyright Crash Course The section on Building on Others’ Creative Expression discusses the limits of Fair Use.
  • Daily Blog Tips: Copyright Law: 12 Dos and Don’ts offers some great tips on what can and can’t be used not only in Blogs but in any publications.

(1) Justia.com offers daily summaries of US Supreme Court, Appellate Court, and State Supreme Court decisions.


Leave a comment

Filed under Copyright, Genealogy, Laws and Legal Decisions

Pinterest: Should You Worry about Copyright?

Guest Blogger – Gena Philibert-Ortega,  Gena’s BlogFood.Family.Ephemera

Social networking has benefitted genealogists through resource sharing, the ability to make connections with other genealogists and learning opportunities. There’s no doubt that using social networking websites can help genealogists further their research.

As we become consumers of new websites we also have to learn how that website works, what their terms of service are and how it affects us. One good example is Facebook. Genealogists new to Facebook often worry about their privacy and whether participation in a social network community will make them vulnerable to hacking or invade their privacy.

A new type of bookmarking website has become a favorite of genealogists. Pinterest < http://pinterest.com/> is currently available only after you request an invite. It bills itself as a “content sharing service.” The main idea is that it provides you the opportunity to “pin” favorite images to a virtual board. Depending on your interests these boards might include such things as favorite recipes, decorating ideas or  book covers. Genealogists have used it to create boards showing their ancestors and other family history topics.

So what’s the problem? Pinterest sounds like a good idea, pinning images to a virtual bulletin board that you can share with others. However, if I were to say that I have started a website where you can post other people’s articles to a virtual board for you to share with others, there might be some discussion about copyright and plagiarism.

Pinterest knows there can be copyright issues with their service. In fact they have recently changed their Terms of Service and made it easier to report improperly sourced content.  In their Terms of Service’s Acceptable Use Policy  it states:

“You agree not to post User Content that: …infringes any third party’s Intellectual Property Rights, privacy rights, publicity rights, or other personal or propriety rights…Contains any information or content that you do not have the right to make available under any law or under contractual or fiduciary relationships…”  < http://pinterest.com/about/use/ >

So why shouldn’t people just see it as flattering or free advertising if you use Pinterest to “pin their images.” Most people wouldn’t knowingly take other people’s writings and pass them off as their own without proper permissions, yet you are doing that when you pin something. There can be several problems with pinning images that you don’t own aside from the copyright or publishing right of the person you took the image from. For example, the site that you “ borrowed” the image from may have purchased that photo for a specific use and therefore they don’t own the rights to it. In cases where I have purchased photos from archives for publication in a book or on my blog , the contract I have with them is for one specific use.  Republishing it on Pinterest is violating their copyright. That means that they could decide to push a case of copyright infringement against you. Now will they do that? I don’t know but it’s a possibility.

A great blog post on this topic can be found on the DDK Portraits Website. In her post entitled  Why I Tearfully Deleted my Pinterest Inspiration Boards   Kristen Kowalski writes about Pinterest’s Terms of Service and what users have the right to pin and what they don’t. (Because there is a copyright statement limiting what can be quoted from her blog post, I  recommend you just go ahead and read it).

Am I making a case for not using Pinterest? No, in fact I think it’s a great way to share information about ancestors. And you should use it to post  content that you own or that you have gained permission to use from the copyright holders. What a great, simple, visual way to share a family’s story.

What I am saying is be careful about what you post. If the image does not belong to you, then ask permission. Yes, I realize that is a hassle but by using Pinterest you are affirming that you are the owner of the image or that you have permission to post it. Infringing on someone’s intellectual property is wrong, plain and simple. It doesn’t matter if you use their materials in a blog posting and you don’t attribute it or you pin an image from their website or blog because you like it. No, it’s not flattering and it’s not free advertising, it’s unethical. As genealogists we need to be mindful as we navigate the social network sphere and make sure that we give credit where it is due.

Leave a comment

Filed under Copyright, Ethics, Genealogy